Does Being Organic Matter with Soap? (The Truth About Your "Squeaky Clean" Skin)
Transparency Note: We independently select these products based on research and user reviews. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.
Updated: Dec 27th 2025
I used to be a skeptic. To me, "organic" was just a buzzword used to justify a $9 price tag on a bar of bubbles. I figured as long as the soap smelled like a "mountain breeze" and got the dirt off, it was doing its job.
But then I started looking into why my skin felt tight and itchy every winter, despite using "moisturizing" big-brand bars. What I discovered changed my bathroom routine forever: most of what we buy at the grocery store isn't actually soap, it’s a synthetic detergent.
If you’re building a Non-Toxic Bathroom, understanding the difference between "soap" and "detergent" is the first step toward healthier skin.
The "Squeaky Clean" Lie
You know that "squeaky" feeling when you rinse off? That’s not actually a sign of cleanliness; it’s the sound of your skin’s natural oils being completely stripped away.
Traditional, non-organic soaps often use Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS). It’s the same stuff used to degrease car engines. It creates a massive, sudsy lather that feels luxurious, but it leaves your skin's protective barrier in tatters. Organic soaps, on the other hand, use the traditional Saponification process—mixing plant oils (like coconut or olive) with an alkali.
3 Reasons Organic Actually Matters
1. The Glycerin Factor In mass-market soap production, the glycerin (a natural humectant that pulls moisture into your skin) is often removed and sold off to make expensive lotions. In organic, cold-pressed soap, the glycerin stays in the bar. You’re essentially moisturizing while you wash.
2. The "Hidden" Fragrance Loophole When you see the word "fragrance" or "parfum" on a non-organic label, it can legally represent hundreds of undisclosed chemicals, including phthalates (known endocrine disruptors). Organic soaps use essential oils. If it smells like lavender, it’s because there is actual lavender in it—not a chemical cocktail.
3. The Environmental "Afterlife" Everything you wash off goes down the drain and eventually back into our water systems. Synthetic surfactants and plastic microbeads don't break down easily. Organic soap is biodegradable. It’s the only choice that aligns with a Zero-Waste lifestyle.
The Real-World Trade-offs (What Nobody Tells You)
I want to be honest with you: switching to organic isn't all sunshine and roses. There are two things that catch people off guard:
The "Mush" Factor: Organic soap doesn't have synthetic hardening agents. If you leave it in a puddle of water, it will turn into a soggy mess by morning. You must use a draining soap dish (like our DIY Beeswax Soap Dish) to let it dry out between uses.
The Lather Adjustment: You won't get those "bubble bath" style suds. Organic soap has a creamier, low-profile lather. It's still cleaning you; it just isn't putting on a show.
Quick Soap Audit
Next time you’re shopping, flip the bar over. If you see these, put it back:
Parabens: Used as preservatives but linked to hormonal issues.
Triclosan: An antibacterial agent that the FDA has actually banned in consumer hand soaps, but it still sneaks into some "deodorant" bars.
Synthetic Dyes: Usually labeled as "D&C Red No. 27" or similar. They serve zero purpose for your skin and are purely for shelf-appeal.
The Verdict
Does organic matter? Yes. Not because it’s "trendy," but because your skin is your largest organ. It’s porous. If you wouldn't feel comfortable rubbing a chemical degreaser on your face, you probably shouldn't be using it in your daily shower.
Start with one bar. Try it for two weeks. I bet you’ll find you need about half as much body lotion as you used to.
My Organic Toolkit
The "Lather Booster": Natural Sisal Soap Saver Bag. If you miss the big bubbles of synthetic soap, put your organic bar in one of these. It exfoliates your skin and creates a much richer lather naturally.
The Best Starter Bar: Dr. Bronner’s Organic Sugar Soap. It’s a classic for a reason—it’s fair trade, organic, and works for everything from your hands to your hair.
For the Countertop: Glass Amber Soap Dispensers. If you prefer liquid soap, buy in bulk and use glass. It prevents plastic leaching and looks much better in a sustainable bathroom.